Found - The Best Peanut Butter Cookie On the Internet

We scoured the internet for the most crave-worthy recipes, baked every single one of them, and did a blind taste-off. Keep clicking to see our ranking. The winner is worth the wait.

#5 Rick Martinez: crunchy and crumbly

#4 A Cozy Kitchen: out-of-this world flavor

#3 Jessie Sheehan: intensely chewy

#2 Ovenly: Rich & Chewy (dairy-free and gluten-free)

#1 Broma Bakery: ticks ALL the boxes

Click the link for full reviews and all the recipes.


Our Top 10 Most Popular Recipes