I have a feeling that most women’s “desert island” makeup choice would be mascara. There’s nothing that adds polish and prettiness quite like it, but there are also about a thousand different options (with new ones hitting the market daily) claiming longer, thicker, curlier, fuller, or more natural lashes. How’s a girl to choose? We polled our beauty council of experts to find out the one brand of mascara that’s earned their loyalty and spill their tried-and-true tips for the perfect application.
*image source: listal
Serge Lutens Beauté Mascara
This is the best mascara I’ve found for that cool girl look. I hate to look like I’m trying too hard and this mascara puts on just the right amount to define your lashes and give you a slight bedroom eyes vibe.
–Â @laneycrowell, Founder of Crowell Lane Creative
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
This mascara is just incredible. It’s one of those items where I used it, loved it, tried to use something similar, and then when I went back to it, was wowed all over again. Now it’s my pick for life!
–@tararasmus, Beauty Editor & Author of Camille Styles Decoder Series
Benefit Roller Lash Super-Curling and Lifting Mascara
This mascara really does curl (after an unfortunate lash-breaking incident, I avoid eyelash curlers) and adds tons of volume. One coat gives you a clean, minimal look, and you can easily layer it for more drama.
-Dawn Spinner Davis, Beauty Director at Total Beauty
W3LL People Expressionist Mascara
I love that I don’t have to worry about any unnecessary chemicals going near my eyes with this clean mascara. Dab the end of the wand on a piece of tissue every time before using so you can use the end to separate lashes and completely wipe down the brush every 3/4th use for a clean slate.
-Nadine Abramcyk, Co-founder of @tenoverten
DIOR Diorshow Mascara
Pro Tip: Invest in an eye lash curler, it will enhance any mascara you use by miles!
-Samantha Wennerstrom, Could I Have That?
Benefit They’re Real! Lengthening Mascara
I already have pretty long and full lashes, but this mascara makes it look like I have lash extensions. That’s amazing.
–Nikki Chanel, Naturally Curly
L’OrĂ©al Paris Voluminous Butterfly Mascara
I’ve tried all the pricey mascaras, but this drugstore buy is hands-down my favorite. One coat makes lashes full, fluttery and longer than I ever thought possible, but leaves no clumps in its wake. I hold the wand at the base of lashes, then wiggle it back and forth all the way to the tips for the most eye-opening effect.
-Camille
Milk Makeup Ubame Mascara
This mascara lengthens and separates, without making my lashes look spidery.Â
-Lauren Caruso, Beauty Director at Style Caster
LancĂ´me Grandiose Extreme Mascara
I have gone through so many mascaras in the past three years, but am currently loving LancĂ´me’s Grandiose Mascara. You don’t need heavy duty eye makeup remover to take it off and the brush is so easy to use!Â
-Jen Pinkston, The Effortless Chic
RMS Volumizing Mascara
I love this mascara because it’s all natural, goes on smooth and makes my lashes look amazing.
–@jennikayne, Designer
L’OrĂ©al Voluminous Carbon Black Mascara
Pro Tip: Scrap the idea that waterproof mascara is only good for pool days. Waterproof formula also means sweat, tear, rain, and humidity proof…aka life proof. Apply a thin layer on top of  your regular mascara and stay smudge-free the whole day! Bonus: because you’re applying regular mascara first, it’s still really easy to take off with make up remover.
–@laura_dominguez, Editorial Intern
Make Up For Ever Excessive Lash Arresting Volume Mascara
This mascara is definitely one of the best I’ve tried, great for volume and lift!
–@katiejanehughes, Makeup Artist