Growing up, Thanksgiving was always at my grandparents’ house. They would take care of the turkey, stuffing, and a few other sides, and my mom and aunts would bring everything else for the big meal. I had one aunt that would always bring store-bought, stale sugar cookies. Another aunt would make sweet potato casserole that was eerily similar to baby food. With cups of sugar dumped into it. Needless to say, those dishes were always a bit of a disappointment.
When I got a little older, my mom took over hosting. She’s a major control freak and did all the cooking to make sure everything was up to standard. Now I host Thanksgiving and, well, the apple doesn’t far fall from the tree. I do all the cooking and have pretty strict guidelines on what I’m serving. But every year, I also end up going to a potluck Friendsgiving.
I tend to get a little nervous that people will forget about the event and pick up something gross at the last minute or choose to make a recipe that doesn’t travel well. To help avoid Friendsgiving food faux pas this year, I’ve rounded up the most crowd-pleasing, potluck-friendly recipes broken out by course.
Scroll on for the recipes, and forward this as a PSA to all your friends!
Main Course
In most cases, the main course (the turkey!) will be taken care of by the host. But I’ve been to a few Friendsgivings where the host doesn’t necessarily want to host 10 people, shell out $40 on a turkey, and take on the responsibility of actually cooking the bird. Luckily, there are plenty of turkey and fall-inspired main courses that can perfectly replace a whole roasted bird. Note: if you’re not the host, but you’re bringing a main, I recommend finishing these recipes off at the host’s house.
Non-Vegetarian
Skillet Pot Pie from Sally’s Baking Addiction
Sausage, Cherry, and Sage-Stuffed Turkey Breast from Camille Styles
Turkey and Stuffing Meatballs from Blenditarian
Vegetarian
Pumpkin Stuffed Shells from Damn Delicious
Brown Butter Pumpkin Pasta from Camille Styles
Side Dishes
A good potluck side dish is one that you can transport in a single dish and easily make ahead of time or finish off at the host’s house. One of the benefits of a Thanksgiving potluck is the freedom to put your own twist on classic recipes. Maybe this year you could bring croissant stuffing instead of traditional stuffing or make potato gratin stacks instead of mashed potatoes.
Fall Salad with Kale, Brussels Sprouts, and Delicata Squash from Amanda Frederickson
Honey Maple Roasted Carrots from The Café Sucre Farine
Herby Mushroom Croissant Stuffing from Half Baked Harvest
Potato Gratin Stacks from Delish
Crispy Brussels Sprouts with Radishes, Bacon, & Dates from Camille Styles
Melting Sweet Potatoes from Feel Good Foodie
Desserts
For reasons I’ll never understand, most people request “just a little bit” of whatever dessert is offered on Thanksgiving. So it’s important to bring desserts with easily adjusted serving sizes or to make dishes that taste great as leftovers.
No-Bake Pumpkin Mascarpone Pie from Camille Styles
The Easiest Apple Crumble from Camille Styles
No-Bake S’mores Pie from Brown Eyed Baker
Slow Cooker Pumpkin Cobbler from The Gunny Sack
Chocolate Pecan Slab Pie from Camille Styles
No-Bake Caramel Apple Pudding with Gingersnap Crust
Bevvies
If someone else is bringing wine or your group isn’t full of wine drinkers, the best next option is a fall cocktail. The below recipes are either batch cocktails you can make ahead of time or super simple cocktails that only require three or four ingredients. You don’t want the guests working too hard to make a drink!
Apple Brandy Harvest Punch from Camille Styles
Thanksgiving Rum Punch from Southern Living
The Campfire Sour from Camille Styles
Fall Sangria from Pretty Plain Janes
Slow Cooker Apple Cider from Number 2 Pencil
Those stuffed shells look SO GOOD!
xoxo
Cathy, your Poor Little It Girl
https://poorlittleitgirl.com
Hi, the stuffed shells looks delish but its not vegetarian unfortunately. the recipe has ground chicken and ground sausage in the sauce! 🙁
oh no! Updated with an equally yummy looking pumpkin stuffed shells recipe that’s actually vegetarian!
This is perfect, I’m heading to a Friendsgiving in a couple weeks and was trying to decide what to bring! These all look delish.